Needlessly Cynical Reactions to Comic Book News
Posted by Dorian in cynical, gay issues, Marvel, my fanboy entitlement is showing again, nerds ruin everything- In a particularly stunning display of how the vast majority of comic book nerds, no matter how patiently you explain it to them, actively refuse to get it, at the now no longer worth reading (now that all the good writers have left for Robot 6), Blog@Newsarama, writer J. Caleb Mozzocco engaged in a rather sad bit of gay-baiting in aid of a joke that, frankly, wasn’t the slightest bit funny in the first place.
The real fun starts when readers point out what an incredibly stupid, not to mention potentially offensive move Caleb’s little joke was, prompting increasingly hysterical and defensive reactions from both Caleb and fellow Blog@ writer Troy Brownfield. For Christ’s sake, they even pull out a sad variation of the “I can’t be homophobic, I have gay friends” defense.
It was the most pathetisad spectacle of the week. At least until the New York Comic-Con started.
- I thought the dumbest thing I’d ever heard of was the latest revival of the New Mutants comic, the fourth for those of you keeping count. It’s always sort of sad to see Marvel wallowing in shitty 80s nostalgia like this. It’s so contrary to the image they like to present of themselves as a corporation that it almost feels like a betrayal of their core principles. I mean, DC has been publishing Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman comics for 70-plus years; I expect them to look to their past for inspiration from time to time (though, honestly guys, bringing Barry Allen back? There’s a limit, you know?). Marvel is supposed to be the hipper, younger, forward-looking company.
I suppose this is just them finally admitting that their core audience is man-children unwilling to let go of their childhoods.
- Of course, the absolute stupidest thing I’ve heard so far (non-politically) this week was the annoucement of the Dark Wolverine series. I’ll let you all take a laugh break now.
…
Got it out of your system? Good.
I mean, really? Dark Wolverine? That’s what you think the comic industry needs? A “darker, grittier, edgier” version of Wolver-frickin-ine? And then, to top it all off, the series stars, not Logan, but
PoochieDaken, Wolverine Jr.? If X-23 was created to make a certain segment of fandom feel better about their masturbatory fantasies, what audience is Daken created to satisfy? Fangirls who didn’t have quite enough people to pair Logan up with in their slash stories? - Of course, some of this makes sense when you consider that the man in charge had this to say about fan complaints about the number of cross-overs in Marvel books these days:
“We’re going to do Marvel Slumber Party,” Quesada joked in response to a question about the pattern of crossovers. He said “giving the characters a rest,” as the fan had suggested, would mean “a bunch of books where nothing happens.”
Either he’s being disingenuous and deliberately misrepresenting the people who think there are too many event books coming out from Marvel too close together, or he genuinely thinks that not having a book tie-in to some larger story means “nothing happens.” I’m not sure which position should insult Marvel fans more.
- Of course, the real tragedy of all this is, that while discussing how face-palmingly stupid all the above is with friends, I was suddenly struck with a really good idea for a Marvel book. Too bad I’d never actually get into a pitch meeting with the company.
I don’t bash DC enough for that.






Entries (RSS)
Is Colleen Coover doing Marvel Slumber Party?
Quesada, listen to Mr. Hale. This would be like printing money.
Yeeeaaaah, because Wolverine was too light and fluffy a character.
The only thing good to come out of Daken was Ares’ ‘Wolverine f**ked your mum!’ line in Dark Avengers (another stupid title – we can’t be far away from Dark X-Men, surely?).
I was suddenly struck with a really good idea for a Marvel book. Too bad I’d never actually get into a pitch meeting with the company.
Ah, all you need is a mouthpiece to play Abe Simpson to your Bart & Lisa.
Oh, come on. The umpteenth New Mutants relaunch has got nothing on the nostalgia-fest that is X-Men Forever.
I don’t know… A skateboarding Wolverine does sound pretty awesome.
Wow, I was pretty surprised to see me mentioned when stopping by postmodernbarney.com, as I do daily. Surprised, and a little bummed out. I don’t really feel the need to respond to every Newsarama poster who misreads something, but I’m surprised that that offended you because, frankly, I expected better from you.
I mean, “Gay-baiting?” Really? That was gay-baiting? Seven words making fun of the fact that hey, superheroes seem kinda gay (something that what, 20% of your own posts do?) and making fun of the impulse of making fun of superheroes for seeming kinda gay itself?
If so then, yes, I admit it, this particular comic book nerd does not, in fact, get it. You haven’t explained it to me before though, patiently or otherwise, nor has anyone else. So go for it: How is that offense? How is it gay-baiting? What was sad and wrong about my posting those dozen words?
Caleb–If Richard, Chris and Bully explaining it to you couldn’t get you to see why it was inappropriate, I certainly can’t.
Gentlemen, we’ve found the male version of Valerie D’Orazio. Caleb, does it really matter that you don’t understand why what you did was so offensive? Most people when confronted with the fact they have offended a person or a group of people apologizes whether or not they understand why. I’m gonna miss Everyday Is Like Wednesday…
In re: “Dark Wolverine,” nothing says “dark” like generic frat-boy “tribal” tattoos. Ugh.
Otherwise, please put Colleen Coover and Paul Tobin on “Marvel Slumber Party.” I would buy every issue.